A bitter pill for hoffmannla roche 26 february 2018 by martin herz and justin lindeboom it takes two to tango. Its core role is the regulation of monopolies, which restrict competition in private industry and produce worse outcomes for consumers and society. Due to the challenges of extracting text from pdfs, it will have odd formatting. A commentary on article 101 tfeu by rick busscher, martin. The majority of cases involve a solution to the negative external effects on the environment. Jul 11, 2012 treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu article 101. Assessing whether a horizontal agreement has an anticompetitive object or actual or potential restrictive effects on competition firstcheck whether article 1011 tfeu applies it is necessary at the outset to check whether an exemption from article 1011 tfeu might apply. This treaty and the treaty on european union constitute the treaties on which the union is founded. This juxtaposition is at the heart of article 101 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu.
This welfare perspective contradicts with the commission guidelines. The relationship between article 1011 and article 101. These include, for example, pricefixing or marketsharing cartels. For the purposes of these guidelines, references to article 101 of the tfeu should be understood as references to article 81 of the ec treaty. It is plausible that an exclusivity obligation has anticompetitive effects when applied by a dominant firm, even though it covers a small part of the market. The following is a more accessble plain text extract of the pdf sample above, taken from our competition law notes. This article reconstructs the agreement concept based on theories of legal interpretation and contract as well as comparative law insights. Free competition is a vital part of the functioning of the internal market which is why it is imperative that provisions are in place to prohibit any restrictions that. The enforcement of article 101 tfeu what has happened to.
The dogmatic of article 101 tfeu and information exchanges. Articles 101 and 102 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu prohibit anticompetitive business practices. Articles 101 and 102 are a matter of public policy which must be automatically applied by national courts eco swiss, 1999 any individual can rely on a breach of article 101 and 102 ec before a national court courage v crehan, 2001 any individual can claim compensation for the harm suffered where there. As a result, agreements aimed at partitioning national markets are in principle restrictive of competition by object. Damages actions for breach of articles 101 and 102 tfeu. Witt, anne, the enforcement of article 101 tfeu what has happened to the effects analysis. The term undertaking is a eurospeak word for any persons or firms in an enterprise, and is used to describe those engaged in an economic.
The following shall be prohibited as incompatible with the internal market. Critically discuss how eu law as applied under article. Twosided markets and the appeals in cartes bancaires and mastercard. The unions action on the international scene, pursuant to this part, shall be guided by the principles, pursue the objectives and be conducted in accordance with the general provisions laid down in chapter 1 of title v of the treaty on european union. Pursuant to article 101 3 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu, agreements between undertakings that restrict competition within the meaning of article 101 1 tfeu may be declared compatible with the internal market if they contribute to promoting technical or economic progress or to improving the. The tests of illegality under articles 101 and 102 tfeu professor p. Ibanez colomo payfordelay and the structure of article. Article 53 and 54 of the eea agreement are essentially the same provisions and effectively extend european competition law to cover the eea countries, i. Most directorates have a 1 with effect from 1 december 2009, articles 81 and 82 of the ec treaty have become articles 101 and 102 respectively of the tfeu.
Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. From time to time, the european commission issues nonbinding notices providing clarification of the competition. This is not the case, however, where as in coditel ii an. Tfeu 101 applies to horizontal and vertical agreements. Based on article 101 of tfeu the commission has these tasks 22. The tests of illegality under articles 101 and 102 tfeu. This entails a discussion of the meaning of undertaking and association of undertakings, including the. Resale price maintenance and the limits of article 101 tfeu. Results will shed light on the so called grey area, in. Absolute territorial protection, for in stance, is in principle re strictive by object and is very unlikely to meet the conditions set out in article 101 3 tfeu.
Article 10 of the treaty on the functioning of the. Article 101, 102 formerly articles 81 and 82 and before that. Articles 101 and 102 are a matter of public policy which must be automatically applied by national courts eco swiss, 1999 any individual can rely on a breach of article 101 and 102 ec before a national court courage v crehan, 2001 any individual can. In assessing licensing agreements under article 101 of the treaty, the existing analytical framework is sufficiently flexible to take due account of the dynamic aspects of technology rights licensing.
Article 101 of the treaty on the functioning of the. Article 101 1 or fulfilling the conditions of article 101 3, as the case may be, for the period of time required to recoup the investment. Despite the importance of the agreement concept under art. Proceedings for the application of articles 101 and 102 tfeu. Reconsidering the application of eu competition law to vertical price restraints ioannis apostolakis ll. Article 101 tfeu does not specifically ban cartels, instead declaring as illegal all agreements, decisions and concerted practices which are anticompetitive and which distort the single market. Article 101 tfeu is one of the three pillars of eu competition law. Article 101 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union prohibits cartels and other agreements that could disrupt free competition in the european economic areas internal market. Iv, issue 8 november 2016 6945 articles 101 and 102 tfeu are the most prominent treaty provisions on competition. Which goals count in article 101 tfeu public policy and. Commission notice on best practices for the conduct of.
European union eu competition law acknowledges the need to protect competition in the common market, while at the same time fostering effective collaboration where necessary between enterprises where this would benefit consumers. The objectives of eu competition law a normative analysis list of content 1. Apr 23, 2015 competition law webinar article 101 1. Developments under articles 101 and 102 tfeu in 2010. This chapter examines the relationship between article 1011 and article 101 3. Thursday 25 april 10 am tutorial room 7 friday 26 april 11 am tutorial room 10.
The two sets of provisions are in substance identical. Hence, there will often be times when a restriction of competition is required which illustrates that anticompetitive conduct between undertakings is not always rendered illegal. It prohibits restrictive agreements between independent market operators acting either at the same level of the economy horizontal agreements, often as actual or potential competitors, or at different levels vertical agreements, mostly as producer and distributor. Article 101 tfeu specifies the rules applicable to the behaviour of undertakings. Act 1998 the act andor article 101 1 article 101 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union the tfeu. The european commission has prosecuted 717 undertakings for cartel behavior in 100 cartels since 1990. Indeed an agreement may be regarded as having a restrictive object even if it does not have the restriction of competition as its sole aim but also pursues other legitimate objectives. Competition law webinar article 101 linkedin slideshare. Tuesday 23 april 10 am tutorial room 8 tuesday 23 april 5 pm tutorial room 8 friday 26 april 9 am tutorial room 7 bclbbl students. Strikingly, apart from a tangential reference in the odd opinion of an advocate general or one order of the president of the general court. The chapter i prohibition provides that agreements between undertakings, decisions by associations of undertakings andor concerted practices which. The public enforcement of articles 101 and 102 tfeu under. It looks at the central question of which agreements, decisions and concerted practices have as their object or effect the prevention, restriction or distortion of competition for the purposes of article 101 1 and at the issue of which agreements are held to infringe article 101 1 but meet the critera for. It explains the terms employed in article 101 1 and how they are interpreted and applied.
Article 101, 102 formerly articles 81 and 82 and before. Dec 14, 2016 therefore, there is every reason to prohibit it as restrictive by object under article 101 1 tfeu. The two sets of provisions are, in substance, identical. Pdf the concept of agreement under article 101 tfeu. Start studying eu law competition law article 101 tfeu. With effect from 1 december 2009, article 81 of the ec treaty has become article 101 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu.
Eu law competition law article 101 tfeu flashcards quizlet. The secondary legislation in the eu consists of regulations and directives. Regulation ec no 12003 on the implementation of the rules on competition chapter 14. The object and effect restriction of article 1011 tfeu. University of leicester school of law research paper no. The object and effect restriction are mechanisms for ascertaining whether or not an agreement restricts competition. The european commission, national competition authorities, and national courts enforce articles 101 and 102 under powers conferred by regulation 12003. Market failures, transaction costs and article 1011 tfeu. Article 101 of the treaty on the functioning of the european. Articles 37, 106 and 345 tfeu for public undertakings and articles 14, 59, 93.
It is the extent to which an agreement may affect trade between member states that decides whether eu. Critically discuss how eu law as applied under article 101. Article 101 tfeu is one of the most prominent treaty provisions on competition. Market integration is an objective of article 101 tfeu. The general prohibition in article 101 is followed by a nonexhaustive list of examples of anticompetitive practices such as price fixing and market sharing.
The following shall be seen as incompatible with the internal market. For the purposes of this decision, references to articles 101 and 102 of the tfeu should be understood as references to articles 81 and. The online content platform for edward elgar publishing. This chapter examines the relationship between article 101 1 and article 101 3. Article 101, 102 formerly articles 81 and 82 and before that 85, 86 the two fundamental european competition law provisions were articles 85 and 86 of the treaty of rome, the treaty that founded the european economic community eec that evolved into the european union and remains, though amended, the fundamental eu constitutional document. Apr 23, 20 article 101 2 tfeu states that agreements and decisions by associations of undertakings that contravene article 101 1 tfeu are null and void. In this paper it will discuss the general framework of both articles by analyzing all the elements of the articles, such us. Another example is found in article 102 tfeu case law. Aims of article 101 tfeu the main aim of article 101 is to provide redress to those affected by any restrictions that are placed on free competition within the internal market. The text of article 102 provides the following, any abuse by one or more undertakings of a dominant position within the internal market or in a substantial part of it shall be prohibited as incompatible with the internal market in so far as it may affect trade between. Articles 101 to 109 tfeu and protocol no 27 on the internal market and competition, where it is made clear that fair competition is included in the objective of the internal market in article 33 tfeu.
A critical analysis posted on july 11, 2012 by john dudovskiy each business entity operating within the european union eu is bound to operate within the boundaries of legislation issued by the government of the home country of the business, as well as, the rules and. Article 102 of the treaty on the functioning of the european. The public enforcement of articles 101 and 102 tfeu under council regulation no 12003. Oct 24, 2016 hence, there will often be times when a restriction of competition is required which illustrates that anticompetitive conduct between undertakings is not always rendered illegal. M glasgow submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of phd in law school of law college of social sciences february 2016. Article 101 prohibits cartels and anticompetitive agreements, while article 102 prohibits abuse of a dominant position. It concerns hard core restrictions of competition like cartels as much as efficiency enhancing agreements.
Where it cannot be established that the object of the agreement is anticompetition, the commission nca would than have to establish that the effect will be anticompetition, in order to establish a breach under article 101 1. This paper aims to analyze the historical development of competition law in the european union, the eu treaties, regulations and directives, which guarantee the protection of competition in the european community. Article 102 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union formerly article 82 of the treaty establishing the european community is aimed at preventing undertakings who hold a dominant position in a market from abusing that position. Agreements that restrict competition by object under. The antitrust manual of procedures does not contain binding instructions for. Positive effects on competition and article 101 tfeu. This treaty organises the functioning of the union and determines the areas of, delimitation of, and arrangements for exercising its competences. Commission notice on best practices for the conduct of proceedings concerning articles 101 and 102 tfeu text with eea relevance. Article 102 of the treaty on the functioning of the. Oct 28, 2011 it basically states that since the measure falls within 1011 tfeu then article 101 prohibits it. In this perspective importance takes also the statefunded aid granted directly by member states, in cases when it distorts or is likely to distort competition and adversely affects trade between member states. Particular restrictions that fall within the impugned category are therefore automatically seen as having the object of restricting competition under article 101 1 tfeu. Dg competitions manual of procedures for the application of articles 101 and 102 tfeu is an internal working tool intended to give practical guidance to staff on how to conduct an investigation applying articles 101 and 102 tfeu. Treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu.
This chapter discusses the text and scheme of article 101 which prohibits agreements, decisions and concerted practices which restrict competition and may affect trade between member states. How does case law relate to the guidelines and the welfare perspective. Capability vs likelihood in the context of articles 101 and. Every referral, throughout the dissertation, to article 101 goes towards tfeu. Its purpose is to control anticompetitive behaviour entered into between different undertakings. In my view, under normal circumstances, and in proper application of the courts case law, the court should have said that it was up to national courts to assess whether the conduct at issue could benefit from article 10, the assessment of. Anticompetitive agreements are prohibited regardless of whether they are. However, it is silent on the fate of concerted practices. It is the second key provision, after article 101, in tfeu competition law. Guidelines on the application o f article 1011 tfeu, oj 2004 c 10197.
They do not take into consideration of the view that the aim of an agreement is not to restrict competition. Treaty on the functioning of the european union and. Article 101 tfeu, notion of undertaking and succession of. Apr 05, 2016 article 101 tfeu is one of the most prominent treaty provisions on competition. How does article 10 tfeu case law relate to ec guidelines. Oft, article 101 3 a discussion of narrow versus broad definition of benefits oft discussion paper. This work is intended for educational use only, it does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon to advise clients on legal matters.
Article 101 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu prohibits agreements between companies which prevent, restrict or distort competition in the eu and which may affect trade between member states anticompetitive agreements. These two treaties, which have the same legal value, shall be referred to as the. Consolidated version of the treaty on the functioning of the. Dg competition is administratively organised in directorates, each consisting of three to five units. Communication from the commission guidelines on the.
Eu ws8 competition law article 101 tfeu flashcards. Eu competition law eu competition law merger legislation. Agreements that restrict competition by object under article. General provisions on the unions external action article 205. Mar 21, 2010 b to lay down detailed rules for the application of article 101 3, taking into account the need to ensure effective supervision on the one hand, and to simplify administration to the greatest possible extent on the other.
431 641 828 1276 1026 795 504 375 1013 1095 814 275 1505 1464 455 121 1144 153 100 257 700 908 667 55 908 549 2 1129 911 599 312 1080 972 125 1157 1246 1141 773